Compare / SD Bullion
SD Bullion review
Affiliate disclosure: some links to the platforms on Metals.now may earn us a commission if you sign up or pay. It never costs you more, and no platform pays to be listed or to change what we write. How we rate
Good for
- Price-checkers paying by e-check or wire who want published buyback bids and cheap segregated storage.
Skip it if
- You want to pay by card above $5,000, by PayPal above $500, or with American Express.
SD Bullion started in 2012 and says it has shipped more than 2 million orders since. Its founder won an Ernst & Young Entrepreneur Of The Year award for Michigan and Northwest Ohio in 2023. It sells bullion more than collector coins, and it competes on price: its about page says it offers "the very lowest prices for bullion online". A lawsuit now disputes that line, as we explain below.
What it costs
On Nov 21, 2026 SD Bullion listed a random-year 1 oz American Gold Eagle at $3,735.79 for one to nine coins by check or wire, against a spot price of $3,549.23 shown on the same page. That is $186.56, or about 5.3%, over spot, and the lowest Eagle price of the dealers we could read that day (APMEX was $3,794.97). Twenty or more coins were $3,715.79 each.
Those are cash prices. Its payment page says cards and PayPal are not eligible for the 4% cash discount, while e-check (up to $10,000) and paper checks are. Shipping and insurance are free over $199 and $9.95 below. Insurance in transit is capped at $10,000 by USPS First Class and $25,000 by Priority, and ends when the package is signed for. If you've told your carrier to leave packages without a signature, SD's insurance won't cover yours.
The limits
SD Bullion takes Visa, Mastercard and Discover only up to $5,000, PayPal only up to $500, and no American Express. Bank wire is the only option above $20,000 and isn't offered under $2,500. Pay late and the order can be cancelled with any market loss plus a 5% cancellation fee.
Selling and storage
It publishes indicative bid prices: a random-year Gold Eagle bid was $3,480.66 on Nov 21, and the page says its listed bids are for sales of more than 10 oz of gold. Buy at $3,735.79 and sell back at that bid the same day and you lose $255.13 a coin, about 6.8%, with no change in the gold price. Sales need at least 2 oz of gold or 40 oz of silver, so one coin can't be sold back on its own; the price is locked by phone, and payment follows within 1–3 business days after processing.
SD Depository stores metal allocated and segregated in your name, insured under a Lloyd's of London policy, at 0.29% a year for gold and 0.39% for silver, with a $9.99 monthly minimum, after three free months. That is less than APMEX's 0.55% and $15 minimum at any size: $10,000 of gold pays the $119.88 annual minimum, and $100,000 pays $290.
Record
In July 2025 a buyer filed a proposed class action in federal court in San Diego, Vickery v. SD Bullion Inc., claiming its "lowest price" advertising is "literally false". He says he later found the same gold coins $102 cheaper per coin elsewhere. The suit also names YouTube channels that promoted SD. These are allegations, not findings, and we found no regulator action. Our own snapshot found SD cheapest on one coin on one day, which proves nothing either way.
Our take
SD Bullion had the best Gold Eagle price we saw and the clearest buyback bids, and the cheapest vault storage we found. It ranks below APMEX on its tight card limits and on the pending suit over the very claim it leads with. Check its price against one other dealer before you buy.
The facts
- Premiums & fees
- On Nov 21, 2026 SD Bullion listed a 1 oz American Gold Eagle (random year) at $3,735.79 for one to nine coins by check or wire, $186.56 or about 5.3% over the $3,549.23 spot it displayed, and $3,715.79 for 20 or more. Cards and PayPal don't get its 4% cash discount, so they cost more.[1][2]
- Products & minimums
- Orders over $199 ship and are insured free in the US; $199 or less pays a flat $9.95. Insurance is capped at $10,000 by USPS First Class and $25,000 by USPS Priority, and ends once the package is signed for. Since 2012 SD Bullion says it has shipped more than 2 million orders.[3][4]
- Payment & shipping
- Visa, Mastercard and Discover are accepted up to $5,000 and PayPal up to $500, neither with the 4% discount; e-check (up to $10,000) and paper checks get it. Bank wire is the only method above $20,000 and isn't offered under $2,500. No American Express. Late payment can bring market loss plus a 5% cancellation fee.[2]
- Buyback & storage
- SD Bullion buys back at least 2 oz of gold or 40 oz of silver, locks the price by phone and pays within 1–3 business days after processing; it publishes indicative bid prices for sales of more than 10 oz of gold (a random-year Gold Eagle bid was $3,480.66 on Nov 21, 2026). SD Depository stores metal allocated and segregated in your name, insured under a Lloyd's of London policy, at 0.29% a year for gold and platinum and 0.39% for silver, with a $9.99 monthly minimum, after three free months.[5][6]
- Regulators & complaints
- A proposed class action filed in July 2025 in federal court in San Diego (Vickery v. SD Bullion Inc., 3:25-cv-01915) claims SD Bullion's "lowest price" advertising is false; the buyer says he later found the same coins $102 cheaper per coin elsewhere. These are allegations, not findings. SD Bullion's about page still says it offers "the very lowest prices for bullion online". We found no regulator action. Bullion dealers aren't licensed like banks or brokers, so there is no single regulator file to read: search your state attorney general's site and the BBB before a large order.[7][4]
Sources
- SD Bullion: American Gold Eagle coins, check/wire price tiers and displayed spot (Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- SD Bullion: payment and pricing, limits and the 4% cash discount (checked Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- SD Bullion: shipping policies and insurance limits (checked Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- SD Bullion: about us (checked Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- SD Bullion: sell to SD Bullion, minimums and bid prices (listed bids are for over 10 oz of gold) (Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- SD Bullion: SD Depository storage, 0.29% gold / 0.39% silver a year, $9.99 monthly minimum (checked Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- Top Class Actions: SD Bullion class action claims company falsely advertises its prices (Oct 31, 2025) topclassactions.com