Physical gold vs GLD (and SLV): what you actually own
How owning gold coins or bars differs from GLD or SLV shares: ownership, expense ratio vs premiums and storage, delivery, custody risk and the 28% tax rate.
In this article 7 sections
If you typed gld.now or slv.now, you probably want to know how the big gold and silver funds compare with owning the metal itself. We don't sell either and won't tell you which to choose. This guide sets out the differences that are matters of fact: what you own, what it costs, where the metal is, and how it's taxed. Fund figures are from the funds' own pages and documents, checked Nov 21, 2026.
What do you own when you buy GLD?
Shares in the SPDR Gold Trust, a trust that holds gold bars. According to its January 2026 FAQ2, the trust's gold is held by two custodians, JPMorgan Chase Bank and HSBC Bank, in vaults in London, New York and Zurich. The trust's net asset value is worked out each day from the ounces it holds, valued at the LBMA Gold Price PM, less accrued expenses. The shares trade on NYSE Arca like a stock, through any brokerage account.
You don't own particular bars, and you can't take delivery yourself. The FAQ says the trustee deals only with "Authorized Participants" in blocks of 100,000 shares; an individual who wants to exchange shares for gold would have to arrange it through a broker. In practice, owning GLD means owning a claim on a pool of gold that you will almost certainly sell as shares, not collect.
SLV, the iShares Silver Trust, works the same way for silver; its fund page3 lists a 0.50% sponsor's fee.
What do you own when you buy coins or bars?
The specific pieces, outright. Nobody stands between you and the metal: no trustee, custodian or broker. That's the whole appeal, and it's also the whole burden. You pay a premium over spot to buy, accept a lower bid to sell, and either store the metal yourself or pay someone to. Our guides on premiums, selling and storage go through each cost.
Which costs more to hold?
They charge in different ways: a fund mostly charges every year, while physical metal mostly charges up front and on the way out.
| $10,000 of gold | GLD shares | Gold Eagles, vaulted |
|---|---|---|
| To buy | Your broker's commission, if any, and the market bid-ask | ≈5.3% over spot (SD Bullion, wire) |
| Each year | 0.40% ($40), taken inside the fund | $180 at APMEX's vault (its $15 monthly minimum; 0.55% above about $32,700), or your own safe and insurance |
| To sell | Market bid-ask, during market hours | Dealer bid: $68.57 under spot at SD Bullion |
Sources: GLD fund page1, SD Bullion prices7 and bids8, APMEX storage10, Nov 21, 2026. Fund fees change; check the current prospectus.
GLD's fee isn't billed to you. The trust sells small amounts of gold2 to pay its expenses, so the gold behind each share slowly declines over time. A physical coin never shrinks, but storing it costs something too, whether that's a vault fee or a safe and the insurance rider your homeowners policy probably needs.
Does GLD track the gold price exactly?
Closely, but not exactly. The FAQ explains2 that the trust's aim is for its shares to reflect the price of gold less the trust's expenses. Its net asset value is fixed once a day from the LBMA Gold Price PM, while the share price is set all day by buyers and sellers on NYSE Arca, influenced by the gold price and its effect on that value. The trust also publishes an indicative intraday value based on the spot price. So the share price can drift slightly from the value of the gold behind it during the day, and over the years the expense ratio is a steady drag against the metal's own price. A coin has no drag of that kind, but its value to you is whatever a dealer will bid, which is below spot.
Where is the risk in each?
- The fund. You depend on the trust, its custodians and the market. The FAQ says2 each custodian's insurance does not cover the full amount of gold it holds, their liability is limited by the custody agreements, and a responsible party might not have the resources to cover a loss. On the other side, it reports that an outside firm, Bureau Veritas, counts the bars twice a year, and the CFTC and FINRA6 describe exchange-traded products as a fully regulated way to get metals exposure.
- Physical metal. You depend on yourself and your dealer. Theft, loss and fire are on you, a standard homeowners policy covers very little bullion, and fake or overpriced coins are a risk if you buy from the wrong seller. See the red flags.
Are GLD and SLV taxed like physical gold and silver?
Generally yes, which surprises people who expect stock treatment. GLD is a grantor trust, so its income and expenses flow through to shareholders. Its FAQ says2 that gains on shares held more than a year are generally taxed at a maximum 28%, because selling an interest in a trust that holds collectibles counts as selling collectibles. If your ordinary rate is lower, the lower rate applies; shares held a year or less are taxed at ordinary rates. The iShares Silver Trust's 10-K4 carries the same 28% heading for SLV. That's the same cap the IRS applies to physical collectibles5.
One quirk: because the trust sells gold to pay expenses, you technically have a tiny taxable sale each year. The FAQ says brokers aren't required to report it on Form 1099-B, though some do, and the trust publishes an example of how to calculate it. More in gold and silver taxes.
So which fits what?
Put plainly, without recommending either: a fund suits someone who wants gold's price in a brokerage account, can sell whenever the market is open, and accepts that the metal is held by others. Coins and bars suit someone who wants the metal itself in hand, accepts higher costs to get in and out, and has a plan to store and insure it. Both rise and fall with the metal's price, and both can lose value.
Sources
- SPDR Gold Shares (GLD): fund page, expense ratio and custodians (checked Nov 21, 2026) spdrgoldshares.com
- SPDR Gold Trust: FAQ, tax, custody and redemption (Jan 2026) files.spdrgoldshares.com
- iShares Silver Trust (SLV): fund page and sponsor's fee (checked Nov 21, 2026) ishares.com
- iShares Silver Trust: Form 10-K, tax section on the 28% collectibles rate (SEC) sec.gov
- IRS: Topic no. 409, capital gains and losses (28% collectibles rate) irs.gov
- CFTC and FINRA: 10 things to ask before buying physical gold, silver or other metals cftc.gov
- SD Bullion: American Gold Eagle coins, check/wire price tiers and displayed spot (Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- SD Bullion: sell to SD Bullion, minimums and bid prices (listed bids are for over 10 oz of gold) (Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- APMEX: storage with Citadel Global Depository Services (checked Nov 21, 2026) apmex.com
- APMEX: Citadel storage fees, 0.55% a year with a $15 monthly minimum (checked Nov 21, 2026) apmex.com
Facts last checked November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at editor@metals.now.