Compare / Kitco

Kitco review

Affiliate disclosure: some links to the platforms on Metals.now may earn us a commission if you sign up or pay. It never costs you more, and no platform pays to be listed or to change what we write. How we rate

Good for

  • Larger buyers (over $5,000) who want an established non-US dealer and storage outside the US.

Skip it if

  • You are buying or selling less than $5,000: shipping, insurance and the sell minimum work against you.
Visit Kitco

Kitco is best known for its price charts and news site. Its online store is run by Kitco Metals Inc. from Montreal, with counters in Canada and the northeastern US, and it ships to US customers. It is the only dealer here that isn't American.

What it costs

We didn't capture Kitco's coin prices on Nov 21, 2026. Its fees are where it differs. Orders under $5,000 pay $15 shipping, and every order pays insurance of 0.65% of the metal value ($6.50 per $1,000), or 0.80% to Washington State and 0.99% to Texas. On a single $3,700 gold coin that adds about $39, which the US dealers here don't charge on orders over $199. Shipping is free from $5,000; the 0.65% insurance still applies.

The usual 4% discount applies to wire, check, online bill payment or money already in your Kitco account. New US customers can pay by card or PayPal up to $10,000, by check up to $25,000 (held 3 business days) or by wire without limit, within three business days.

Selling and storage

Kitco's minimum to sell physical metal is $5,000, five times the $1,000 at APMEX, JM Bullion and BGASC and well above SD Bullion's 40 oz for silver (about $1,700 at spot); only SD's 2 oz gold minimum is higher. Insured shipping to Kitco usually costs $6.50 per $1,000, and dropping a package at its counters can cost up to $70. Its allocated storage holds metal segregated and insured in Canadian and Hong Kong vaults, gold in minimum increments of 10 oz. If you want metal outside the US that is the point; if you don't, it is a complication.

Record

In 2010 and 2011 Canada's federal and Québec tax authorities assessed Kitco for about C$313 million in sales-tax refunds, alleging a "fraudulent tax scheme" with suppliers. Kitco contested the assessments and in 2011 continued trading under Canada's creditor-protection law. A Québec court ruled for Kitco on a related set-off question in 2016. We couldn't confirm how the assessments themselves ended, and we found no US regulator action.

Our take

Kitco is a long-standing dealer, but for most US buyers its fee structure costs more on small orders and its $5,000 sell minimum makes it awkward to sell part of a holding. It ranks last here for those reasons, not for its record.

Visit Kitco

The facts

Premiums & fees
Orders under $5,000 pay $15 shipping, and every order pays insurance of 0.65% of the metal value ($6.50 per $1,000; 0.80% to Washington State, 0.99% to Texas). On a $3,700 coin that's about $39 on top. Wire, check, bill pay or account funds get a 4% discount. We didn't capture its coin prices.[1][2]
Products & minimums
Shipping is free from $5,000 to the continental US; standard delivery is 2–5 business days and can take 10–15 by USPS in rare cases. Kitco doesn't ship to APO addresses.[1]
Payment & shipping
First-time US customers can pay by card or PayPal up to $10,000, by bank or personal check up to $25,000 (checks are held 3 business days), or by wire without a limit. Payment is due within three business days.[2]
Buyback & storage
Kitco's minimum to sell physical metal is $5,000. Shipping a sale to Kitco usually costs $6.50 per $1,000 for insurance, and drop-off at its counters can cost up to $70 a package. Its allocated storage keeps metal segregated and insured in Canadian and Hong Kong vaults, gold in 10 oz minimum increments.[3][4]
Regulators & complaints
In 2010–2011 Canadian and Québec tax authorities assessed about C$313 million in sales-tax refunds, alleging Kitco took part in a "fraudulent tax scheme" with suppliers; Kitco contested them and in 2011 continued trading under Canada's creditor-protection law (CCAA). We couldn't confirm how the assessments ended. No US regulator action found. Bullion dealers aren't licensed like banks or brokers, so there is no single regulator file to read: search your state attorney general's site and the BBB before a large order.[5][6]

Sources

  1. Kitco: shipping and insurance FAQ (checked Nov 21, 2026) online.kitco.com
  2. Kitco: payments and fees FAQ (checked Nov 21, 2026) online.kitco.com
  3. Kitco: how to sell to Kitco FAQ (checked Nov 21, 2026) online.kitco.com
  4. Kitco: allocated storage FAQ (checked Nov 21, 2026) online.kitco.com
  5. Legal 500 / Mondaq: the Kitco Metals Inc. decision on tax set-off in a restructuring (2016) legal500.com
  6. Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada: CCAA record for Kitco Metals Inc. ised-isde.canada.ca

Visit Kitco · Compare all platforms