Gold vs silver: premiums, storage space and sales tax
Gold vs silver for physical buyers, on facts not forecasts: premiums over spot, how much $10,000 of each weighs, sales tax rules, selling minimums and taxes.
In this article 7 sections
People who decide to own some physical metal usually ask next whether it should be gold or silver. We won't tell you which will do better; nobody can, and sellers who claim to know are selling. What we can lay out are the practical differences that don't depend on a forecast: what each costs over spot, how much room it takes, how sales tax and selling minimums treat it, and how the IRS taxes it. Prices are as dealers published them on Nov 21, 2026.
How do the premiums compare?
Silver carries a much larger premium relative to its metal value. On Nov 21, 2026 APMEX listed a 1 oz Silver Eagle1 at $57.72 each for 1–19 coins by check or wire, $15.99 over its own spot price of about $41.73: a premium of roughly 38%. The same day SD Bullion listed a 1 oz Gold Eagle2 at $3,735.79 by check or wire, $186.56 or about 5.3% over spot.
Part of the reason is fixed cost. Minting, packing, shipping and insuring one coin costs roughly the same whatever it's made of, and that cost is a much bigger share of a $42 ounce of silver than of a $3,549 ounce of gold. Silver bars and rounds carry their own premiums, so compare them on the same page if premium is what matters to you.
What does $10,000 buy, and how much does it weigh?
| Nov 21, 2026, check or wire | Gold Eagles (SD Bullion, 1–9 tier) | Silver Eagles (APMEX, 100–499 tier) |
|---|---|---|
| Coins for up to $10,000 | 2 | 176 |
| You pay | $7,471.58 | $9,982.72 |
| Metal value at spot | $7,098.46 | $7,344.48 |
| Premium as a share of what you pay | 5.0% | 26.4% |
| Fine metal | 2 troy oz (62 g) | 176 troy oz (5.47 kg, ≈12.1 lb) |
Our arithmetic on the dealers' listed check or wire prices: two Gold Eagles at $3,735.79 and 176 Silver Eagles at APMEX's 100–499 price of $56.72 (one to 19 coins were $57.72). Metal value uses each dealer's own spot: SD Bullion's $3,549.23 for gold and APMEX's $41.73 for silver. A troy ounce is 31.1034768 grams7. Gold's price per coin leaves money unspent at this budget; a gold bar or fractional coins would use more of it, at their own premiums.
On Nov 21, 2026 one ounce of gold cost about 85 times one ounce of silver ($3,549.23 against $41.86 on SD Bullion's ticker2). That ratio is why silver takes up so much more room: a few gold coins fit in an envelope, while the silver equivalent is a heavy box. If you plan to keep metal at home, that affects the safe you need; if you plan to store it in a vault, the dealer vaults we review charge by value, not volume, so the space matters less. See storage.
Is silver easier to buy in small amounts?
Yes, which is much of its appeal: one Silver Eagle cost $57.72 on Nov 21, 2026, against $3,735.79 for a 1 oz Gold Eagle. But small orders carry extra costs that are easy to miss. APMEX and SD Bullion both ship free only above $199 and charge $9.95 below that4, so a $100 order pays about 10% in shipping on top of silver's premium. SD Bullion's shipping terms5 are the same. Kitco charges $15 shipping under $5,000, plus 0.65% insurance on every order. If you plan to buy a little at a time, the shipping threshold matters as much as the coin price. Fractional gold coins exist too, but at a much higher premium per ounce; see bars vs coins.
Do you pay sales tax on gold and silver?
It depends on your state, and the rules often turn on the size of the purchase, which affects silver buyers more. California is a clear example. Its Regulation 15998 exempts sales of bullion and numismatic coins only when they are made "in bulk": a single transaction with a market value of $2,000 or more (the figure since July 1, 2023, which can be adjusted). A single 1 oz gold coin clears that on its own. A $500 order of silver coins doesn't, so it is taxed.
Where the metal is delivered can matter too. JM Bullion's storage page notes that metal stored in its Nevada or Texas vaults9 falls under those states' sales tax rules rather than your home state's. Check your own state revenue department's rules, and the tax line at checkout, before you compare prices across dealers.
Is one easier to sell than the other?
Both are widely traded, but dealer minimums are set in ounces or dollars, and they bite differently. SD Bullion buys back at least 2 oz of gold or 40 oz of silver3. APMEX, JM Bullion and BGASC set a $1,000 minimum per sale, which a single gold coin clears but a small stack of silver may not; Kitco needs $5,000. Shipping silver back to a dealer also means shipping more weight. Our selling guide compares the terms.
Are gold and silver taxed differently?
Not federally. The IRS treats both as collectibles, so a gain on metal held more than a year is taxed at a maximum rate of 28%10 rather than the 0%, 15% or 20% that applies to most stocks, and short-term gains are taxed as ordinary income. The details, including how to work out your cost basis, are in gold and silver taxes.
Is silver "cheap" compared with gold?
You'll hear the gold-to-silver ratio used as a buy signal: the claim is that when it's high, silver is due to catch up. That is a forecast, and we don't make forecasts. Both metals moved sharply in the days before we wrote this: SD Bullion's ticker showed gold down $87.79 (about 2.4%) and silver down $1.59 (about 3.7%) in Friday's session alone. The CFTC warns11 that gold and silver prices can be highly volatile, like other commodities, and that holding a mix of assets is safer than putting everything in one.
Sources
- APMEX: 1 oz American Silver Eagle (random year), price tiers by payment method (Nov 21, 2026) apmex.com
- SD Bullion: American Gold Eagle coins, check/wire price tiers and displayed spot (Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- SD Bullion: sell to SD Bullion, minimums and bid prices (listed bids are for over 10 oz of gold) (Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- APMEX: shipping FAQ, free over $199, $9.95 below (checked Nov 21, 2026) apmex.com
- SD Bullion: shipping policies and insurance limits (checked Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- Kitco: shipping and insurance FAQ (checked Nov 21, 2026) online.kitco.com
- NIST: conversion factors for precious metal sales (troy ounce) nist.gov
- California CDTFA: Regulation 1599, coins, medallions, bullion cdtfa.ca.gov
- JM Bullion: storage through TDS Vaults, rates and handling fees (checked Nov 21, 2026) jmbullion.com
- IRS: Topic no. 409, capital gains and losses (28% collectibles rate) irs.gov
- CFTC: Lies versus facts, the truth behind gold and silver IRA scams (2024) cftc.gov
Facts last checked November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at editor@metals.now.