How to sell gold and silver: buyback spreads and 1099-B
How to sell gold and silver bullion: dealer buyback minimums and payment times, what the spread costs, when a dealer files IRS Form 1099-B, and what you owe.
In this article 7 sections
Selling bullion is simpler than buying it, but it's where the cost of the round trip becomes real. A dealer buys at its bid, which sits below its asking price and often below spot. This guide covers how the big online dealers buy back, what the spread costs, when the IRS hears about your sale, and how to avoid the worst offers. Terms are as the dealers published them on Nov 21, 2026.
How much less than spot will a dealer pay?
It depends on the item and the dealer, so always ask for the bid on the exact thing you're selling. One published example: on Nov 21, 2026 SD Bullion's bid1 for a random-year 1 oz Gold Eagle was $3,480.66, $68.57 (1.9%) under its displayed spot of $3,549.23; SD says its listed bids are for sales of more than 10 oz of gold. Its selling price for the same coin was $3,735.792 by check or wire. The difference, $255.13, is the spread: 6.8% of what a buyer paid that day.
The CFTC and FINRA7 define the spread as the gap between a dealer's buy and sell prices and note that the wider it is, the harder it is to come out ahead; some fraudulent dealers have charged spreads of more than 300%. Coins bought at a big markup are the hardest to sell well, because a dealer buying them back pays for the metal, not for the sales pitch.
How do the online dealers' buyback terms compare?
| Dealer | Minimum per sale | How the price is locked | Payment |
|---|---|---|---|
| APMEX | $1,000 | Online or by phone | Next business day after authentication; shipping deducted |
| SD Bullion | 2 oz gold / 40 oz silver | By phone | 1–3 business days after processing |
| JM Bullion | $1,000 | Online, any hour | 10+ business days after receipt (its notice on Nov 21, 2026) |
| BGASC | $1,000 | By phone | Not stated on the page we read |
| Kitco | $5,000 | By phone or online, or at the market price on arrival | Usually 24–48 hours after verification; $35 shipping plus $6.50 per $1,000 insurance if Kitco arranges it |
Sources: APMEX3, SD Bullion1, JM Bullion4, BGASC5, Kitco6 sell pages, checked Nov 21, 2026.
What are the steps to sell to an online dealer?
- Get quotes for the exact items from two or three dealers within a few minutes of each other on a weekday, so spot is the same.
- Lock the price. Once you accept, the dealer holds that price and you're committed to send the metal. Read the dealer's terms for what happens if you change your mind or the package is late: Kitco, for one, guarantees a locked price only if the package is postmarked within one business day and arrives within 10.
- Ship it insured. APMEX sends prepaid insured labels; at other dealers check who pays shipping and insurance, because it comes out of what you receive.
- Wait for authentication and payment. The dealer checks the items before paying. Keep your tracking number and photos of what you sent.
What does it cost to get paid?
Check the payout terms as well as the bid, because they come out of what you receive. Kitco, for example, lists its payout options6: a check by regular mail is free but takes about 10 to 15 business days to arrive, a check by courier costs $30, and a domestic wire $40. It usually pays within 24 to 48 hours of receiving and verifying a shipment, and charges a $35 flat fee plus $6.50 per $1,000 of insurance if you use its shipping. APMEX deducts shipping from your payment, per its selling page3. At Kitco's $5,000 minimum, using its shipping and a courier check, that's $35 plus $32.50 insurance plus $30: $97.50, about 2% of the sale. Subtract those costs from each dealer's bid before you compare.
Should you sell to a local shop or a cash-for-gold buyer instead?
A local coin shop avoids shipping and insurance, and it's worth asking for its quote alongside the online bids. The offers to be careful with are the ones that won't name a price before they have your metal. In testimony to Congress the FTC flagged "cash for gold" buyers8 who melted down jewelry and precious metal without first giving the seller a quote. Know your item's melt value (fine weight times spot) before you walk in, and don't mail metal to anyone who hasn't given you a price in writing.
Does the dealer report your sale to the IRS?
Sometimes. Under the IRS instructions for Form 1099-B9, a dealer must report a sale of gold, silver, platinum or palladium only when the metal is in a form, and a quantity, that would satisfy a CFTC-approved regulated futures contract. The IRS gives the example of a single gold coin: not reportable when approved contracts require at least 25 coins. Sales by one customer within a 24-hour period are aggregated, and the exception doesn't apply if the dealer knows or has reason to know a customer is splitting sales to avoid reporting. APMEX describes its own 1099-B practice on its selling page3.
What records should you keep?
Your original invoices, showing the date, what you bought and the total you paid. Under IRS Topic 70310, cost includes sales tax and other expenses connected with the purchase, so premiums, shipping and tax you paid all count toward your basis and reduce your gain. Keep the dealer's purchase confirmation when you sell, too. Gains and losses go on Form 8949 and Schedule D, as IRS Topic 40911 explains.
Sources
- SD Bullion: sell to SD Bullion, minimums and bid prices (listed bids are for over 10 oz of gold) (Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- SD Bullion: American Gold Eagle coins, check/wire price tiers and displayed spot (Nov 21, 2026) sdbullion.com
- APMEX: selling to APMEX, $1,000 minimum, payment and 1099-B (checked Nov 21, 2026) apmex.com
- JM Bullion: Sell To Us, $1,000 minimum and payment timing (checked Nov 21, 2026) jmbullion.com
- BGASC: sell silver and gold, $1,000 minimum (checked Nov 21, 2026) bgasc.com
- Kitco: how to sell to Kitco FAQ (checked Nov 21, 2026) online.kitco.com
- CFTC and FINRA: 10 things to ask before buying physical gold, silver or other metals cftc.gov
- FTC: testimony on consumer protection issues in coin and precious metal investments (Sep 2010) ftc.gov
- IRS: Instructions for Form 1099-B, sales of precious metals irs.gov
- IRS: Topic no. 703, basis of assets irs.gov
- IRS: Topic no. 409, capital gains and losses (28% collectibles rate) irs.gov
Facts last checked November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us at editor@metals.now.